A route is not a line
Drawing a line from one socket to another takes a second. Drawing a route that can actually be built takes longer. It has to stay clear of shafts and ducts, follow the corridor where that makes sense, and bend as rarely as possible. Each of these judgements is simple. It is their sum that makes the work painstaking.
Route A to B is the feature in Pembris Electrical that takes on this work. You select two devices, and it proposes a route that accounts for the building. Here we explain what makes the task harder than it looks, what a good route has to account for, and why the result is always a proposal.
Many equally short paths
Between two points there is rarely one right path. Take a purely mathematical example: a grid of 10 × 10 one-metre squares. Travel along the grid lines from the bottom-left corner to the top-right, one step up or to the right at a time. There are 184,756 different paths, and every one of them is exactly the same length.
Length alone, then, cannot decide which is best. What sets them apart is, among other things, how often they change direction, and most of them change direction many times. Only 182, about one in a thousand, have three bends or fewer.
Every bend is a fitting in the model and more resistance when the cable is pulled. To the person pulling the cable, two routes of equal length can be very different.
The number grows quickly with size: on a grid of 20 × 20 squares there are more than 137 billion. And a real building is not an empty grid. It has walls, shafts, ducts and cable trays.
What a good route accounts for
One thing is fixed: a route from Route A to B never crosses what you have set to Avoid, such as shafts and ducts. Within that, a good route is a compromise between considerations that pull in different directions:
- Length. A shorter route means less material and shorter cables.
- Bends. Fewer bends mean fewer fittings and a cable that is easier to pull.
- The zones you have drawn. Areas routes should prefer or stay within, such as a corridor where routes naturally gather. Areas you have closed off are always respected.
None of these can be judged on its own. A shorter route may cost two extra bends, and the way along the corridor is not always the shortest. Balancing them is the task itself.
A proposal, not a decision
Even the best proposal rests only on what the model knows, and you know more. Perhaps a suspended ceiling is going into the corridor, or perhaps access is easier from the other side of the wall.
That is why Route A to B presents the route before it is added, with its length, number of bends, size and everything it crosses. You accept or cancel. If you accept, the route is added as a single step you can undo.
What is added are ordinary conduits and fittings in the model. They appear in the material list, they are checked by Check the routes, and you can change them like anything else you have drawn.
Route A to B is one of the features of Pembris Electrical, now in pilot with its first customers. Read more about Pembris Electrical.